After venturing into Nutter Batter and it having a great taste, I figured why not get the other exclusive in S'mores to see how it stacks up. I have only read one other review and they claimed it was outstanding, so I knew this had to be a scoop!
Upon opening the lid you will see a nice smooth surface of marshmallow ice cream, a small hint of a graham cracker swirl and nice little chips of chocolate which correlate to what the product states as "Marshmallow Ice Cream, Marshmallow Swirls, Graham Cracker Swirls, and Chocolate Pieces". S'mores was everything and above that in this pint. I have to say the base was outstanding, it resembled that of taking a spoon into a jar of fluff and throwing it in your mouth. Wegmans has really stepped up their game.
After the first bite I really started to see the graham cracker swirl and the small brown bits of it run down the middle and sides of the pint. The marshmallow swirls are very hard to pick up on because of the very powerful base which is unique and nothing like I have ever come across before. The small pieces of the chocolate bits you would cram into the middle of a s'mores are a nice texture, not very hard, but still give it a great bite/texture to the overall pint, not to mention the perfect impersonation of a s'mores.
Overall, this pint is everything you could want if you are a s'mores lover. This marshmallow base takes this pint to the next level. It is basically eating a jar of fluff, throw in a nice thick graham cracker swirl, more marshmallow swirl (to add to the overpowering base), and nice little chocolate chunks and that is this pint in a wrap. After the Banana Peel-N and Nutter Batter I have to say Wegmans is giving other big name brands a run for their money. This one ranks up there with one of the best I've had.
Where Bob Found It: Wegmans
Bob's Grade: A